Committee: No Downtown Buildings Higher than 2 Stories
The zoning rule, part of a comprehensive general plan package, is expected to go to council for a vote later this year.
The committee tasked with coming up with the rules that will direct development in San Clemente for decades said no buildings higher than two stories should be allowed in the Del Mar-Camino Real zone.
The General Plan Advisory Committee voted 10-7 with several abstensions to include zoning rules prohibiting buildings three stories and taller in what planners call the "T" zone. The zone includes the length of Avenida Del Mar and several blocks of El Camino Real to the north and south of its Del Mar intersection.
Alan Korsen, one of the spokesmen for the panel, said that polling and focus groups showed residents liked the "human scale" of the city and wanted to preserve it.
"We wanted to stay away from the Huntington Beaches and the Newport Beaches," he said in a phone interview Thursday. "We don't know exactly how they're going to word it, but the GPAC made it clear that it wanted to keep the height limit on Del Mar."
He said the vote was partly in response to Olen Properties' planned 27,000-square-foot retail/restaurant/residential building on El Camino Real across from the Avenida Del Mar intersection.
Project architects assure that the street frontage of the building would be two stories, only increasing to three stories in the center and back where it has frontage on Estrella. Many remain unsatisfied, however, saying the project dwarfs the historic City Hall next door, known as the Easley Building.
"I think the project to go next to historic City Hall is a good idea of what might happen, and I think it was the feeling of the group that this is not what we wanted," Korsen said.
The dissenters who spoke opposed the measure largely on the grounds of property rights, Korsen said.
The completed General Plan is expected to go before the City Council for approval later this year.
The Olen project will go before the San Clemente Planning Commission this month.
Lindsey Hanson
11:20 am on Friday, February 17, 2012
Totally agree! Now are the folks who want to take over the CHI building still interested? I hope so.
Tom Barnes
9:55 am on Saturday, February 18, 2012
A major part of the problem that the proposed three story Olen project creates is the precedent it will set for three stories in the T-Zone. If it is approved at that height there will be other one and possible two story properties that will want to go to three stories.
It is too bad that the Olen people did not talk to San Clemente residents who are opposed to three story buildings before they got this far along. Any project that threatens to split the city is not a good one for San Clemente. Hopefully, something can be worked out that develops the property at the two-story level can be worked out.
James Schumaker
10:54 am on Saturday, February 18, 2012
If you can't build up, maybe you can build out. There are still a few vacant lots in the T zone.