There Is More to School Protection Than Guns

School children do need protection. An armed guard in itself is not the answer. We should look to those who know what it's like to protect and to serve.

We are now in a National Discussion on how to protect our children while they are in school. I watched the talk shows and there is a clear divide on how this might be accomplished. 

I have a suggestion, based on my years in law enforcement. I tend to agree with those who would place armed guards in our schools. But there is more to protection than guns. There is also a way to do this that leaves the authority with the local school district, while excluding the Federal Government, and its spare no expense programs. Each local school district should decide how best to protect the children in their district. This is a local issue and does not involve the Federal Government.

The average security agent can be trained to use a gun and fight back against a person with a gun. I suggest if this is all we do, there will be unnecessary killings. My answer to this problem is retired police officers.

An item of concern is the uniform and “military type appearance” of security.  Retired police officers dressed in sports jackets and slacks, would appear to the children as a grandparent personality, with no stress invoking image.

We have thousands of policemen, especially here in California, who retire at a relatively young age. These people generally look for something to keep them busy after retirement. I would suggest retired police officers should form the basis of the protection unit for our school system. The best system would consist entirely of retired police officers. If there were not enough retired officers, they could act as supervisors and trainers for those with less experience.

Having a gun and knowing how to use it is only part of a good protection program. This is the reason retired military or the National Guard would not be the best choice. They can handle a weapon, they can stop violence with violence, but they don't have experience dealing with street people. A police officer has years of dealing with people on the street under stressful situations. They deal with people most of us will never meet. It is this experience which will be of equal value to the ability to shoot a bad guy. But more important, the experience will save lives. Lives will be saved in the schools, and also the lives of disturbed shooters, who could be talked out of a shooting.

An example is those mentally ill people who believe they are receiving orders from an outside source. These confused people are often on the street and believe God or some space alien is giving them directions. They are often agitated and fearful that this “director” has control of them. They know something is wrong, but can’t quite put their finger on the cause.

This confusion can lead them to arm themselves for protection. One can never be sure where they will identify the danger. They appear to the public as aggressive, dangerous people. These are the types of mentally ill people who can get themselves shot by an inexperienced security person. But an experienced police officer will have dealt with such conditions numerous times. By listening carefully, giving the mentally ill a chance to explain what is happening, the police officer can help them overcome the “director.”   Once calmed and transported to a hospital, they will be helped instead of being shot. In such cases, a possible tragedy would be avoided.

Another is the person trying to commit suicide. Notice how many of these cases involve notes explaining the actions of the shooter.  Given the opportunity a well-trained street cop can often have a positive effect on the outcome of such a
confrontation. Sometimes the difference between a shooting and a good outcome, is noticing the suspect wants to tell you about his complaint against society.   Once the experienced cop gets the conversation going, the chances of avoiding a shooting improves considerably. Even if it goes bad, there has been time to move children from the area.

Retired police officers often volunteer to help the community they served. Sometimes, they are a little short on retirement money and are willing to accept a position offering lower pay.  The community gets the benefit of their experience and they get additional income added to their retirement.

Not every retired officer would be interested in this job. Every experienced retiree who does volunteer to work in the school reduces the expense to hire full time police officers, or part time security guards, to protect the children.

I am nervous about training people to handle guns and then put them in high stress locations such as our schools. A young police officer, after graduating from a police academy, has a training officer. The training officer will ride with them
until they have experience dealing with a number of calls for service. A police officer will have enough experiences, after a month or two on the streets, to protect themselves and the public. A security officer working in a school could go years without getting the same experience.

We should have armed guards in schools. The guards should be retired police officers. The security should be dressed in slacks and a jacket to reduce stress on the children. The guards should be the command presence in the case of violence in our schools. There is experience to show this will save lives.

Every answer does not require the federal government in our local communities.  There is ample proof they don’t have answers in Washington, let’s not let them spread their failed ideas to our local schools.

This post is contributed by a community member. The views expressed in this blog are those of the author and do not necessarily reflect those of Patch Media Corporation. Everyone is welcome to submit a post to Patch. If you'd like to post a blog, go here to get started.

Martin Henderson January 05, 2013 at 02:55 AM
You make some good points, but unfortunately, they aren't seen as victims so we are unlikely to see any concerts for the benefit to wipe out mental illness. It's unfortunate, because it would save many lives -- not only those who suffer but those affected by the actions of the mentally ill. It would be interesting if Gabby Giffords became the torchbearer for mental illness -- might have that concert after all. I'm not going to dispute the "miscarriage of justice" regarding Loggins, but I do take the stance that it's not always so black and white. There are a number of things that could have happened there that would have likely yielded a different result, but everything also happens in a second or two. Lots of very quick decisions, and sometimes indecision creates the tragedy. Had they removed the kids, and without benefit of a taser, cops would likely have had to beat Loggins to subdue him once he tried to retrieve the kids, and that wouldn't have been very pretty on the nightly news and we'd be having a different discussion (though he would, hopefully, still be alive).
JustUs January 05, 2013 at 04:12 AM
" It would be interesting if Gabby Giffords became the torchbearer for mental illness -- might have that concert after all" Yes, Martin. Even after one of their own was cut down by a severely mentally ill man who was able to purchase a gun only 2 months before he committed the act on Giffords, the clowns in Congress refused to even mention the huge problem we have with mental illness in America or address we should combat it. It's all about the money, Martin. They would rather spend our money on causes with a political payoff - like WAR and the "WAR ON DRUGS". heh. And thank you for reconsidering your opinion on the Sgt. Manny Loggins fatal shooting. We pay cops BIG BUCKS to make quick decisions. We pay them as much as medical doctors with only a GED entry educational requirement. The cops messed up royally and made HUGE mistakes that will cost us taxpayers $10M. None of those cops will get fired or even fined. And there are many unanswered questions that the sheriff's office REFUSES to answer. They are hoping for a quick settlement so it goes away and they can bury the damning evidence so the public can't see it in the legal process. If you knew the truth I bet you would be steaming mad. They shot a man and killed him in front of his minor daughters, Martin. A decorated Marine. The ones they salute at all their council and board meetings. But they never saluted Sgt. Loggins at those meetings. Not once. They are all hypocrites.
CDC January 08, 2013 at 08:07 AM
Lets just arm everyone. Who ever is left standing wins... http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CLjNJI54GMM
Joker Joe January 08, 2013 at 05:14 PM
Just sayin' http://myfox8.com/2013/01/06/ga-mom-shoots-intruder-5-times-saves-children/
Joker Joe January 08, 2013 at 05:15 PM
JustUs I see it and totally agree. It is a round robin with a chair taken out each time. We the people have to suck it up.


More »
Got a question? Something on your mind? Talk to your community, directly.
Note Article
Just a short thought to get the word out quickly about anything in your neighborhood.
Share something with your neighbors.What's on your mind?What's on your mind?Make an announcement, speak your mind, or sell somethingPost something
See more »