After Vicious Attack, Pit Bull Returns to San Juan Capistrano

The dog sent a Jack Russell to the veterinarian and the smaller dog's owner to the hospital.

Gelee, photographed by O.C. Animal Care while she was impounded, attacked a neighbor and her dog last month in San Juan Capistrano.
Gelee, photographed by O.C. Animal Care while she was impounded, attacked a neighbor and her dog last month in San Juan Capistrano.

A 70-pound pit bull that attacked a San Juan Capistrano woman and her Jack Russell Terrier last month returned this week to its owners after being tentatively labeled a vicious dog, according to O.C. Animal Care documents.

The incident happened at March 19 in the Los Corrales neighborhood. Helen Welch said she was upstairs in her own house when she heard “dogs barking and obviously in distress,” followed by yelling.

Welch rushed outside to see her neighbor holding her Jack Russell Terrier with blood gushing from her hand, she said. The pit bull, named Gelee, had ahold of “Jack,” while the attacking dog’s owner, Peter Goodwin – also a neighbor – was trying to unhinge them.

“The owner of the pit bull was on the ground, pulling the pit bull by her hind legs, and his knuckles were all bloody,” said Welch, adding that she became more concerned for Jack’s owner.

“There was just blood gushing, spurting out of her hand,” Welch said.

Neither Welch nor paperwork from O.C. Animal Care identified the victim. Goodwin told an Animal Care officer that Gelee got out accidentally.

Welch said she rushed her neighbor to the emergency room at Mission Hospital, while yet another neighbor took Jack to the veterinarian. According to the file, Jack went to Laguna Pet Care Center in Laguna Hills, where he has incurred nearly $1,500 in vet bills.

Jack’s owner “showed me pictures of Jack while he was at the vet, showing major damage to Jack’s rectum, large open lacerations on his back end as well as several punctures,” wrote an Animal Care staffer on a so-called “detail activity card.”

Meanwhile, Jack’s owner required eight stitches in her hand and now suffers limited mobility. Welch said the bites were through the “meaty” part of the victim’s thumb.

The file from Animal Care shows that Gelee was impounded March 23 and quarantined for six days, until 10 days had passed since the bite.

Ryan Drabek, director of OC Animal Care, said Gelee has been tentatively labeled a vicious dog and the Goodwins must adhere to certain restrictions, such as maintaining locked gates, posting warning signs, carrying enough liability insurance.

An administrative hearing will eventually decide to make the vicious dog designation permanent, Drabek said.

“It’s up to the discretion of our agency to do what we feel is necessary to protect the public – that’s what the hearing is for,” he said. 

Dennis Baker April 06, 2014 at 12:46 AM
13 dead by dog attack so far in 2014. 8 killed by ** Pit Bull type dogs / Pit Bull mixes, 3 killed by * Bull Mastiffs / Mastiff Mix, 1 killed by Shepard Mix and Lab Mix and 1 killed by Rottweiler. Child fatalities by dogs (8): Kara Hartrich – 4 – Bloomington IL [Jan 17 - **Pit Bull] Je’vaeh Mayes – 2 – Temple TX [Feb 17 - **Pit Bull] Braelynn Coulter – 3 – High Point NC [Feb 25 - **Pit Bull] Summer Sears – 4 – Tallassee AL [Feb 26 - Shepherd Mix & Lab Mix] Kenneth Santillan – 13 – Patterson NJ [28 Feb - * Bull Mastiff] Raymane Robinson Jr. – 2 – Killeen TX [1 March - * Bull Mastiff] Mia DeRouen - 4 - Houma, La - [March 25 - **Pit Bull] Christopher Malone - 3 - Thornton, MS [Mar 31 - **Pit Bull] Adult fatalities by dogs (5): Christina Bell-Burleson – 43 – Houston TX [Jan 5 - **Pit Bull] Annabell Martin - 80 - Corona CA [Jan 26 - 3 Rottweilers] Klonda Richey – 57 – Dayton OH [Feb 7 – * Mastiff mixes] Nancy Newberry - 77 - Phoenix AZ [Mar 15 - **Pit Bull] Dorothy Hamilton - 85 -Kaufman, TX [Mar 31 - **Pit Bull]
starr April 06, 2014 at 12:27 PM
Dave Solt April 06, 2014 at 03:17 PM
2013 statistics 32 U.S. dog bite-related fatalities occurred in 2013. Despite being regulated in over 700 U.S. cities, pit bulls contributed to 78% (25) of these deaths. Pit bulls make up about 6% of the total U.S. dog population. Source is Dog attack deaths and maimings, U.S. & Canada September 1982 to December 31, 2013, by Merritt Clifton, editor Animal People, December 31, 2013
Matt Gaffney April 07, 2014 at 04:00 PM
Owners of Pit Bulls have a hard time getting Homeowners Insurance. The liability risk is just too great.
Carol April 12, 2014 at 08:27 PM
why was this dog allowed to be returned to our community?


More »
Got a question? Something on your mind? Talk to your community, directly.
Note Article
Just a short thought to get the word out quickly about anything in your neighborhood.
Share something with your neighbors.What's on your mind?What's on your mind?Make an announcement, speak your mind, or sell somethingPost something
See more »